How to apply Monte Carlo simulations

Step by step guide

Monte Carlo simulations are a powerful technique to assess project risks by modeling the probability of different outcomes (e.g., project completion dates or budgets). Here’s a step-by-step guide to applying them to your projects:


Step 1: Define Project Variables and Uncertainties

  1. Identify Key Tasks: Break down the project into individual tasks (e.g., design, development, testing).
  2. Determine Uncertain Variables:
  • For each task, define variables with uncertainty (e.g., task duration, cost, resource availability).
  • Example: Instead of a fixed duration for “backend development,” use a range (e.g., 10–20 days).
  1. Identify Dependencies: Map task dependencies (e.g., Task B can’t start until Task A finishes).

Step 2: Assign Probability Distributions

  1. Choose Distributions: Assign probability distributions to uncertain variables based on historical data or expert judgment. Common distributions include:
  • Triangular: Optimistic, most likely, pessimistic estimates.
  • Normal: Mean and standard deviation (if data is symmetric).
  • Uniform: All outcomes equally likely (rare, but simple).
  • Beta/PERT: For skewed data (common in project management). Example:
  • Task Duration (Triangular): Optimistic = 10 days, Most Likely = 14 days, Pessimistic = 20 days.

Step 3: Build the Simulation Model

  1. Use a Tool:
  • Excel: Use RAND() or add-ins like Palisade @Risk/Crystal Ball.
  • Python: Libraries like NumPy, SciPy, or Monte Carlo simulators.
  • Specialized Tools: RiskAMP, Lumina Decision Systems Analytica, or Simul8.
  1. Model the Critical Path:
  • Create formulas to calculate the total project duration/cost based on task dependencies and variables. Example Excel Formula:
   =TRIANGULAR(10, 14, 20)  // Generates a random duration for a task

Step 4: Run Simulations

  1. Set Iterations: Run the simulation 10,000+ times to generate a range of outcomes.
  2. Capture Results: Track the total project duration/cost for each iteration. Python Example:
   import numpy as np

   iterations = 10_000
   durations = []

   for _ in range(iterations):
       task1 = np.random.triangular(10, 14, 20)  # Triangular distribution
       task2 = np.random.normal(15, 3)           # Normal distribution
       total_duration = task1 + task2
       durations.append(total_duration)

Step 5: Analyze Results

  1. Visualize Outcomes:
  • Histograms: Show the distribution of possible completion dates/costs.
  • S-Curves (Cumulative Probability): Plot the likelihood of finishing by a certain date or budget. Example S-Curve Interpretation:
  • “There’s a 70% chance the project will finish within 90 days and a 95% chance within 110 days.”
  1. Identify Risks:
  • Highlight tasks contributing most to variability (e.g., tasks with the widest duration ranges).

Step 6: Communicate Findings

  1. Report Key Metrics:
  • Confidence Intervals: “We’re 80% confident the project will cost between $120k–$150k.”
  • Critical Tasks: Flag high-risk tasks needing mitigation (e.g., vendor delays).
  1. Update Plans:
  • Adjust timelines/buffers based on simulation results.

Step 7: Iterate and Refine

  1. Update Inputs: Re-run simulations as new data emerges (e.g., mid-project delays).
  2. Compare to Actuals: Validate the model’s accuracy over time and refine distributions.

Example Use Case

Scenario: Software development project with 5 interdependent tasks.

  1. Assign triangular distributions to each task’s duration.
  2. Run 10,000 simulations.
  3. Results show a 65% chance of finishing in 60 days, but a 90% chance in 75 days.
  4. Action: Add a 15-day buffer to the timeline to ensure 90% confidence.

Tools to Simplify Monte Carlo

  1. Excel + @Risk/Crystal Ball: User-friendly for non-coders.
  2. Python: Flexible and free (use pandas, numpy, matplotlib).
  3. Online Simulators: MonteCarlito, RiskAMP.

Key Benefits

  • Quantifies risks (e.g., “What’s the chance of overrunning the budget by 20%?”).
  • Helps stakeholders set realistic expectations.
  • Identifies tasks needing contingency plans.

By integrating Monte Carlo simulations into your planning, you’ll move from deterministic (“best guess”) to probabilistic (“data-driven”) project management. 🔄📊

Discover more from Devops7

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading